Comments on: Dave Navarro Dispells Winner Spoiler http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/ Rock Star Super Nova Fan Site Wed, 07 Jan 2009 08:34:34 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.0.4 by: Jean-Marc Jacques http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-283 Tue, 12 Sep 2006 14:09:21 +0000 http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-283 Dear Dave, My wife and I have been watching Rock Star Supernova from the beginning. We were very deceived to see that you let go Storm. We think that the public vote is a hormone vote, meaning, that many many very young girls (12,13,14 years old) must have voted for the guys(not offense)and that does'nt reflect the reality and that is not a vote for the real talent (and we think that is it what you try to find!!!). On her last performance, Storm was unbeatable. She had really improved a lot from her preceding performances and put in all the things you asked for in the beginning episodes. We thought of a good dramatic surprise to boost your show: would'nt that be something if you were to annonce that the publics'vote was false and you all agreed to bring Storm back for the finals. Would'nt it be a shock! It that is a lie, we think the vote is a lie. So, a lie for a lie ... Just think about it... (like in the song from "Chicago". Maybe, next year you can proceed to have a public's vote and in the same night, a vote from you also for the 3 who have to go the next day and you will make a compilation of the 2 votes. So that way, you will have the power to choose for the talent and still have a opinion from the public and your hands will not be tied. Sorry for our english but we are french Canadian. We are sorry for this year and we are hopping the best for next year. Jean-Marc and Hélène Québec, Canada Dear Dave,

My wife and I have been watching Rock Star Supernova from the beginning. We were very deceived to see that you let go Storm. We think that the public vote is a hormone vote, meaning, that many many very young girls (12,13,14 years old) must have voted for the guys(not offense)and that does’nt reflect the reality and that is not a vote for the real talent (and we think that is it what you try to find!!!). On her last performance, Storm was unbeatable. She had really improved a lot from her preceding performances and put in all the things you asked for in the beginning episodes.
We thought of a good dramatic surprise to boost your show: would’nt that be something if you were to annonce that the publics’vote was false and you all agreed to bring Storm back for the finals. Would’nt it be a shock! It that is a lie, we think the vote is a lie. So, a lie for a lie …
Just think about it…
(like in the song from “Chicago”.

Maybe, next year you can proceed to have a public’s vote and in the same night, a vote from you also for the 3 who have to go the next day and you will make a compilation of the 2 votes. So that way, you will have the power to choose for the talent and still have a opinion from the public and your hands will not be tied.

Sorry for our english but we are french Canadian.
We are sorry for this year and we are hopping the best for next year.

Jean-Marc and Hélène
Québec, Canada

]]> by: Simon Tromans http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-204 Tue, 05 Sep 2006 14:39:23 +0000 http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-204 Been watching the show from here in UK, blows away the cringingly lame mainstream X-Factor we're expected to tune in to. The Big Question - Who is the right fit for the band? Tommy, Gilby and Jason have such established personalities, I really feel for them and the contestants, there's this big chasm inbetween. I mean, hoping to become the frontman for these guys, while showcasing their own abilities; Then each becoming admired in their own right - that's not helping. It's why I can't see any of them fitting in, personally. And that's flipped what the show is really about, launching a band. So... could Supernova witness the house band been fronted by one of the contestants? Can't rule that one out for sure. Well a band will have been launched, so the show will have achieved, in part, what it set out to do. Now that could help with Supernova obstacle no 2., the band with the same name. They are pissed off. So dump the name Supernova, I mean, Frankie goes to Hollywood - Relax keeps springing to mind, anyway, not good (- Is this just a UK thing?). It'll also release Tommy, Gilby and Jason. Bet they didn't foresee any pitfalls with project anyway, can concentrate on making damn fine music instead of been involved in way boring legal turkey twangers. And... in the meantime, hey, it's no great hang for us. We are the audience, we are being entertained. That's Rock. Been watching the show from here in UK, blows away the cringingly lame mainstream X-Factor we’re expected to tune in to.
The Big Question - Who is the right fit for the band?
Tommy, Gilby and Jason have such established personalities, I really feel for them and the contestants, there’s this big chasm inbetween.
I mean, hoping to become the frontman for these guys, while showcasing their own abilities; Then each becoming admired in their own right - that’s not helping.
It’s why I can’t see any of them fitting in, personally. And that’s flipped what the show is really about, launching a band.
So… could Supernova witness the house band been fronted by one of the contestants?
Can’t rule that one out for sure. Well a band will have been launched, so the show will have achieved, in part, what it set out to do. Now that could help with Supernova obstacle no 2., the band with the same name. They are pissed off.
So dump the name Supernova, I mean, Frankie goes to Hollywood - Relax keeps springing to mind, anyway, not good (- Is this just a UK thing?).
It’ll also release Tommy, Gilby and Jason. Bet they didn’t foresee any pitfalls with project anyway, can concentrate on making damn fine music instead of
been involved in way boring legal turkey twangers.

And… in the meantime, hey, it’s no great hang for us. We are the audience, we are being entertained. That’s Rock.

]]> by: Monica http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-201 Tue, 05 Sep 2006 03:23:23 +0000 http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-201 I love Dilana, she is awesome, I love Lucas' voice and his instinct when it comes to changing up the tunes to "fit" his voice...and he does an amazing job...i am in awe of his uncanny ability to capture - without really looking for "involvement" from the audience he does "involve" its almost natural, I love toby.......however, even though he is a showman...he just seem a bit too clean for hangin with the likes of rockstar Tommy.......Gilby and Jason.......no "digs" to them........."not clean" is a good thing............. I would buy a CD with Lucas on it..............not Toby.....even though I love his voice...im a girl that lives and breathes for the bad boy type and when you think Rockstar..thats the image my mind conjures up......I love storms voice...she is just too theatrical for me......talented but wrong venue........Rock on SuperNova.................. I love Dilana, she is awesome, I love Lucas’ voice and his instinct when it comes to changing up the tunes to “fit” his voice…and he does an amazing job…i am in awe of his uncanny ability to capture - without really looking for “involvement” from the audience he does “involve” its almost natural, I love toby…….however, even though he is a showman…he just seem a bit too clean for hangin with the likes of rockstar Tommy…….Gilby and Jason…….no “digs” to them………”not clean” is a good thing…………. I would buy a CD with Lucas on it…………..not Toby…..even though I love his voice…im a girl that lives and breathes for the bad boy type and when you think Rockstar..thats the image my mind conjures up……I love storms voice…she is just too theatrical for me……talented but wrong venue……..Rock on SuperNova………………

]]> by: Denise Bauer http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-176 Thu, 31 Aug 2006 19:08:42 +0000 http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-176 Lukas does a good job, but I'm still not picturing him as the front man of the band. In my opinion he doesn't go out of his way to get the audience involved, and that could hurt him. Toby, on the otherhand, is the "MASTER" when it comes to the audience, he's such a babe magnet. Magni does pretty decent with the audience, but could use a little more interaction. I have a softspot for Magni, and would love to see him win, I feel for him when he misses his little boy!!! I cried when SuperNova flew his family out to see him. How great was that???? Lukas does a good job, but I’m still not picturing him as the front man of the band. In my opinion he doesn’t go out of his way to get the audience involved, and that could hurt him. Toby, on the otherhand, is the “MASTER” when it comes to the audience, he’s such a babe magnet. Magni does pretty decent with the audience, but could use a little more interaction. I have a softspot for Magni, and would love to see him win, I feel for him when he misses his little boy!!! I cried when SuperNova flew his family out to see him. How great was that????

]]> by: Lisa http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-166 Thu, 31 Aug 2006 02:19:43 +0000 http://rock-star-mania.com/rock-star/2006/08/30/dave-navarro-displess-winner-spoiler/#comment-166 I think the winner is clear, and I thought so from the start - Toby Rand seems to be the obvious choice for the band, and would make a great addition to the Supernova. If they actually went for a female lead, the choice is also clear with Dilana, but its hard to say what the band is looking for in a lead vocalist. I loved Rockstar INXS and thats what prompted me to watch Rockstar Supernova - these are truly talented artists already, most in bands of their own unlike shows like American Idol. There really is no comparison - this by far is a great show and the new lead vocalist will truly have a great career ahead - guaranteed. I look forward to watching week after week! Thanks to everyone on the show putting in such hard work week after week to blow us away with! Great job! I think the winner is clear, and I thought so from the start - Toby Rand seems to be the obvious choice for the band, and would make a great addition to the Supernova. If they actually went for a female lead, the choice is also clear with Dilana, but its hard to say what the band is looking for in a lead vocalist. I loved Rockstar INXS and thats what prompted me to watch Rockstar Supernova - these are truly talented artists already, most in bands of their own unlike shows like American Idol. There really is no comparison - this by far is a great show and the new lead vocalist will truly have a great career ahead - guaranteed. I look forward to watching week after week! Thanks to everyone on the show putting in such hard work week after week to blow us away with! Great job!

]]>